One of the great documentaries from independent India, the film is a stunningly photographed saga of an ancient and now politically war-torn land: Kashmir. The celebration of Indian independence in Kashmir begins with the burial of bodies whose deaths took place for unknown reasons. The flag ritually goes up in the heart of Srinagar, Kashmir. But the empty streets and the sulle...
(展开全部)
One of the great documentaries from independent India, the film is a stunningly photographed saga of an ancient and now politically war-torn land: Kashmir. The celebration of Indian independence in Kashmir begins with the burial of bodies whose deaths took place for unknown reasons. The flag ritually goes up in the heart of Srinagar, Kashmir. But the empty streets and the sullen silence that greet India’s claim on Kashmir spark off old questions about freedom and its denial. After 18 years of an armed struggle, with 60,000 dead and nearly 7,000 missing, Kashmir’s people begin to look within their ledger of loss. Using a mix of verité footage, rare archival material, poetry and text, this is a provocative look at Indian democracy, and a reflection on power, resistance and freedom’s terrible thirst.
This is the first of three films on Kashmir, all of which signal the revival of a documentary of rights. It has been filmed by one of India’s leading cinematographers, Ranjan Palit.
我们如何欢庆自由的短评 · · · · · · ( 全部 21 条 )
0 有用 teresa 看过 2013-05-02 03:12:19
以家人的血肉，家园的毁灭我们欢庆自由，这是不应该被忘记的，这纪录片有点有种，大量当时实拍映像，比现在的新闻特写多了
2 有用 欢乐分裂 看过 2011-08-18 14:35:55
为生存、尊严和自由，他们可以抛却性命远离家园；牵涉到的历史宗教人文问题异常复杂，导演在纪实场景中插入许多空镜代替叙事，战火绵延下的诗歌流传，阿三们太牛逼了！
1 有用 夏南 看过 2011-11-29 23:53:41
全片敏感词！哇了个噻
1 有用 SherryOrange 看过 2011-11-30 00:25:31
其实我心中和坐在第一排的七十多岁激动老奶奶有相似的感觉，却按耐住震撼的情绪羞于表达，更不及一个拄着拐杖日日一人跟影展的老爷爷，对他们充满了钦佩。相比之下，那些年纪轻轻就品头论足的过度解读，就真是哗众取宠了。
0 有用 michelle 看过 2011-12-03 18:50:16
很好的剪接，很多珍贵的镜头。赶着去买菜，看完就走了。想着如果能多留一会儿，听听导演和他们的交流也许会理解更多。