绿野仙踪 The Wizard of Oz (1925)

Name: 绿野仙踪 The Wizard of Oz
Genre: 喜剧, 家庭, 奇幻, 冒险
Duration: 1 h 21 min
Cast: 多萝西·德万 Dorothy Dwan, 玛丽·卡尔 Mary Carr, Virginia Pearson Virginia Pearson, 奥列佛·哈台 Oliver Hardy, 拉里·塞蒙 Larry Semon

导演: Larry Semon
编剧: 莱曼·弗兰克·鲍姆 / Frank Joslyn Baum
主演: 多萝西·德万 / 玛丽·卡尔 / Virginia Pearson / 奥列佛·哈台
类型: 喜剧 / 家庭 / 奇幻 / 冒险
制片国家/地区: 美国
语言: 无声
上映日期: 1925
片长: 81 分钟(20.7 fps) / USA: 72 分钟(2005 alternate version)
IMDb: tt0016544

豆瓣评分

暂无评分

想看看过

评价:

绿野仙踪的剧情简介 · · · · · ·

　　This is a pretty weird adaptation of the "Wizard of Oz", bearing only a passing resemblance either to the original book or to the beloved Judy Garland version. The story is much different, and the characters look and act much differently. Frankly, most of it isn't really very good, although for those who enjoy silent films there are some points of historical interest.
　　Instead o... (展开全部) 　　This is a pretty weird adaptation of the "Wizard of Oz", bearing only a passing resemblance either to the original book or to the beloved Judy Garland version. The story is much different, and the characters look and act much differently. Frankly, most of it isn't really very good, although for those who enjoy silent films there are some points of historical interest.
　　Instead of the more familiar story of young Dorothy's trip to Oz, the scenario here has a melodrama centering on a somewhat older Dorothy (Dorothy Dwan), combined with some slapstick involving the Oz characters. In itself, it's not necessarily a big problem to adapt the story (after all, the great 1939 version also made some significant changes from the book), but this one does not really fit together very well, and it certainly does not work as well as the more familiar story. It really looks as if Larry Semon just tried far too hard to put his own personal stamp on the story, instead of simply trying to make a good movie version of the Wizard. It's interesting to see Oliver Hardy as the Tin Woodman, but he doesn't really get a lot to do, and a number of the other characters are ill-conceived, and do not work out well at all. It's also plagued with a lot of excruciating puns in the title cards, plus other similar problems.
　　Some of the finest movies ever made came from this era, when the silents were at their peak, and it should have been possible to make a first-rate adaptation of the Oz story, but unfortunately this isn't it. With its overdone attempts at humor and melodrama, it looks more like the stereotyped images of silent movies that are held by so many ill-informed modern moviegoers. For silent movie fans, there are still a couple of points of interest that might make it worth watching in order to satisfy one's curiosity, but otherwise there's really no particular reason to see it.

我要写短评

绿野仙踪的短评 · · · · · · ( 全部 12 条 )

0 有用仙女蒋鸲鹆看过 2021-06-03 10:33:51

后面像看舞台无限拉长的戏曲，自动给它扣起镲子

0 有用我们在一九八四看过 2022-07-22 11:42:04

经典故事如何配合主演惯常戏路的修改！看的时候直呼这跟39年的是俩故事啊！最开始加了一个做木偶的老爷爷给孙女讲故事，差点串戏到匹诺曹，然后讲oz国女王被丢弃到人间，雨夜鬼片一般，之前有一段众人质问首相。堪萨斯农场场面，这一大段都充分发挥了Larry杂耍不要命喜剧的特点，叔叔追打Larry，Dorothy意外参战，都打乱营了！然后真相大白，女主Dorothy有王位要继承，可是稻草人、铁皮人、狮王都还没... 经典故事如何配合主演惯常戏路的修改！看的时候直呼这跟39年的是俩故事啊！最开始加了一个做木偶的老爷爷给孙女讲故事，差点串戏到匹诺曹，然后讲oz国女王被丢弃到人间，雨夜鬼片一般，之前有一段众人质问首相。堪萨斯农场场面，这一大段都充分发挥了Larry杂耍不要命喜剧的特点，叔叔追打Larry，Dorothy意外参战，都打乱营了！然后真相大白，女主Dorothy有王位要继承，可是稻草人、铁皮人、狮王都还没有出现啊！他们配合不会变魔术的巫师把自己装扮成稻草人等三人组，合情合理！Larry模仿稻草人那段真是绝了！然后在oz与坏人斗智斗勇，保护Dorothy，在地窖误入狮笼打斗，又充分发挥Larry团队不要命喜剧的特点，险象环生，特别吸引人！装箱子那段可太有意思了！最后打败坏人！Larry是不是又落单了？ (展开)

0 有用 megaclaudiolis 看过 2022-07-27 17:01:20

20年代套路和恶趣味太多了，很不好的改编，根本就看不出来是绿野仙踪的故事呃...【美学还是不错惹，btw喜欢这种字体胜过silentina

0 有用 Dracula 看过 2024-03-29 22:46:32 上海

早期默片演员都是杂技高手…

0 有用纯情奶1 看过 2022-09-28 00:28:30 山东

看的72min的。前半段有趣，有点卓别林的感觉，逗笑我好几次，后半段感觉成了好莱坞爆米花大片，但是是一个世纪前的那种😂。编剧居然可以使用绿野仙踪的元素编写出完全不同的故事，像不那么童话了一点的童话故事。挺好玩的但也就那么回事。

> 更多短评 12条

你关注的人还没写过短评

我要写影评

绿野仙踪的影评 · · · · · · ( 全部 0 条 )

添加新讨论

讨论区 · · · · · ·

> 去这部影片的讨论区（全部0条）

以下片单推荐 · · · · · · ( 全部 )

谁在看这部电影 · · · · · ·

第七旅
4月27日看过
Xuq
4月16日想看
Dracula
3月29日看过

43人看过 / 52人想看

订阅绿野仙踪的评论:
feed: rss 2.0

绿野仙踪 The Wizard of Oz (1925)

绿野仙踪的剧情简介 · · · · · ·

绿野仙踪的演职员 · · · · · · ( 全部 29 )

绿野仙踪的图片 · · · · · · ( 图片6 · 添加 )