Troop No. 731 was a secret unit of the imperial armywhich tested biological weapons during WW2. Although its cruel experiments on living people produced thousands of casualties, this activity is still denied by a number of Japanese historians. This documentary reacting to thegrowing historic revisionism consists of two parts: in the firstone history is presented from the Chines...
(展开全部)
Troop No. 731 was a secret unit of the imperial armywhich tested biological weapons during WW2. Although its cruel experiments on living people produced thousands of casualties, this activity is still denied by a number of Japanese historians. This documentary reacting to thegrowing historic revisionism consists of two parts: in the firstone history is presented from the Chinese perspective, thesecond part offers the Japanese interpretation. Usage of thesame shots in both parts of the film ironically demonstrates the potential to misuse any film images.The film was awarded as the Best Documentary Film of 2007 by Woody Vašulka at Jihlava International Festival.
731：两种地狱的短评 · · · · · · ( 全部 2 条 )
3 有用 Yu 看过 2019-03-13 09:00:13
几乎相同的画面，用两种不同的叙事方式。 后半段倒放画面，用的是从日本的角度出发的叙述方式吧。没能看完，目前有点反胃。
0 有用 Claudia 看过 2024-03-27 14:18:54 北京
吴汉章怎么还拍这么一个东西？但是这里面看不到什么吴汉章的痕迹，也很难说难道这些镜头是他拍的吗？一些东北哈尔滨-731旧址及附近的影像碎片。配上英文旁白和一个低沉压抑的节奏音乐，先是正序播放这些影像碎片，拼接在一起，辅以中方视角的旁白；再以同样的顺序拼接，但却倒放每个片段，辅以日方视角（日方官方的说辞）旁白。导演的意图和立场变得模糊起来，我觉得挺可笑的这事儿（731）又不是什么三五千年前的事情。就家... 吴汉章怎么还拍这么一个东西？但是这里面看不到什么吴汉章的痕迹，也很难说难道这些镜头是他拍的吗？一些东北哈尔滨-731旧址及附近的影像碎片。配上英文旁白和一个低沉压抑的节奏音乐，先是正序播放这些影像碎片，拼接在一起，辅以中方视角的旁白；再以同样的顺序拼接，但却倒放每个片段，辅以日方视角（日方官方的说辞）旁白。导演的意图和立场变得模糊起来，我觉得挺可笑的这事儿（731）又不是什么三五千年前的事情。就家里老人七八十岁，八九十岁，和百岁老人那都是见过经历过口口相传过的啊，神经病吧。而且片尾说什么如果真的有731，那美国应该掌握证据，啪啪打脸了吧？埃文·凯尔不就给中国捐回了南京大屠杀的相册吗？小日子真寻思731没证据？叫不醒装睡的人，现世报全都喝核废水然后变畸形吧。日本人去死。 (展开)