探讨配乐如何从另一个感官补充描述被性虐儿童的心理

有剧透!!!!请看完电影再来看!!!!!!
有剧透!!!!请看完电影再来看!!!!!!
有剧透!!!!请看完电影再来看!!!!!!
有剧透!!!!请看完电影再来看!!!!!!
有剧透!!!!请看完电影再来看!!!!!!
有剧透!!!!请看完电影再来看!!!!!!
有剧透!!!!请看完电影再来看!!!!!!
《Mysterious skin》是一部把童年性侵犯拍得最真实和最唯美的电影:真实在对性虐场景的展现和对被性虐儿童的心理刻画,唯美在利用迷幻的英式shoe-gazing配乐从另一个感官补充描述被性虐儿童的心理。
Neil和Brian分别展现被性虐待过的儿童的两种极端心理。
Neil属于放纵型心理,成为男妓,沉溺于能带给他有教练的感觉的中年男人的性爱;Brian属于逃避型心理,自我心理防御机制使他失去被性虐的记忆,并把这段埋藏在潜意识里记忆转化为被外星人挟持的经历,在梦中屡屡梦见伏在他身上、穿着棒球鞋的“外星人”。
以下结合配乐说明。
每当Neil回想与教练的“经历”,配乐就会切换成英式迷幻、沉沦气质的shoe-gazing,不仅中和了性虐片段的真实和主题的沉重,还居然营造出不可思议的梦幻般的的唯美感(我想这也是为什么澳大利亚禁了这部电影,他们认为这电影有可能被恋童癖用来自慰或诱导儿童产生性唤起)。然而,也正是这配乐帮助淡化了教练的唆使、诱导角色,不像一些同类电影(又或是新闻报道)一味地将恋童癖魔鬼化,把一些有过性虐经历的同性恋全“归咎于”是恋童癖的错,似乎没有恋童癖就不会有这些同性恋。
相反地,电影看似轻描淡写,但却一丝不落地刻画了Neil不健康的家庭成长环境对他的影响,以及他潜在的前天性取向。在电影开头,Neil还未加入棒球队之前,当他目睹妈妈和妈妈的男朋友偷欢的时候,他的画外音独白说道:“Seeing him(妈妈的男朋友) like this, whimpering and grunting, like a helpless animal, I couldn't take my eyes off him." 诚然教练的诱导也是造成Neil成为queer很大的因素,但是很明显,Neil本身就对同性有好感,并且享受同性接触。最能体现的一点在Neil第一次见到教练的时候,他立刻就被教练捕获了:“Desire sledgehammered me. He looked like lifeguards, cowboys, firemans I'd seen in the <Playgirl> that my mom kept stashed under her bed." 教练是他的性启蒙,是他的初恋,是他的引导者。这就是为什么当Neil回忆他与教练的经历的时候配乐会是如此缠绵梦幻,因为此时的配乐是从Neil的角度来诠释教练对于他的性意义。这也解释了Neil为何会发展成为放纵型的心理,在无尽的性爱中寻找最初与教练的感觉,沉沦的配乐配上荧幕上消瘦颓废的Neil,画面与音乐配合得如此天衣无缝。
而Brian——Brian是在棒球场上被Neil和教练偶然拣选带回家的,因此Brian没法像本身就有些queer并且也爱着教练的Neil一样,接受并享受与教练的时光,所以对于Brian来说,与教练的5小时不仅是猥亵,更是强奸。然而,当Brian梦到或是努力回想自己“被外星人挟持”的经历的时候,配乐虽然不那么浪漫,但导演却仍然使用迷幻的shoe-gazing配乐。屏幕上Brian的小脸被上下颠倒了过来,很难辨清他真实的表情(更别提纯真的小演员也不可能演出什么来),但这里迷幻的配乐又在向我们传达另一种不同于Neil的信息——很多被性侵犯的儿童,由于在被性侵的过程中产生了性快感,而后经常感觉内疚与自责,不敢面对自己,发展为逃避型人格。正是因为无法接受教练和Neil对他所做的事情,也无法接受分明是在不情愿的情况下却产生的令自己羞愧又困惑的快感,Brian的心理防御机制才会把那5个小时以及之后万圣节的1小时将记忆中抹去,为的是不再让自己从每每回想中受到愧疚的折磨。但记忆虽然被抹去,但其实这段痛苦的记忆携带着更多情感逃匿到潜意识里,这也就是为什么当Brian梦到“被外星人挟持”的梦的时候,被抑制在潜意识里的各种性恐惧、性渴望都浮上水面,而配乐又在悲伤地透露着Brian痛苦、羞愧、难以启齿的性虐经历。
因此整部配乐的拣选,不仅再次体现了Gregg Araki杰出的音乐品味(他的每一部电影里都有用到post-rock, shoegazing),也体现出导演对音乐中的感情、气氛的敏锐的“审美直觉”(我管这叫artistic intuition)和对音乐于情绪的出色的掌控调配力。
----------
马虎写完,准备睡觉去了。欢迎讨论!
最后附上我最喜欢的台词几段:
Wendy: And you have to understand one thing: where normal people have a heart, Neil McCormick has a bottomless black hole. If you don't watch out, you'll get fall in and you'll get lost forever.
********************
Neil: As we sat there listening to the carolers, I wanted to tell Brian that it was over now and that everything would be okay. But that was a lie, plus I couldn't speak anyway. I wish there was some way to go back and undo the past. But there wasn't. There was nothing we could do. So I just stayed silent and tried to telepathically communicate how sorry I was about what happened. And I thought of all the grief and suffering and fucked up stuff in the world, and it made me want to escape. I wished with all my heart we could just leave this world behind. Rise like two angels in the night and magically disappear.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
最后再附上原声带:
Mysterious Skin (Music from the Film) http://www.xiami.com/album/169224
以及不包括在原声带里的歌:
"Golden Hair"
Written by Syd Barrett
Performed by Slowdive
"Galaxy"
Written by Dean Garcia, Toni Halliday
Performed by Curve
"Game Show"
Composed and Produced by Dag Gabrielsen
"Catch the Breeze"
Written by Neil Halstead
Performed by Slowdive
"Crushed"
Written by Elizabeth Fraser, Robin Guthrie, Simon Raymonde
Performed by Cocteau Twins
"Dagger"
Written by Neil Halstead
Performed by Slowdive
"I Guess I Fell in Love Last Night"
Composed and Produced by Dag Gabrielsen
Pianist: Alex Lacamoire
"I Could Do Without Her"
Composed and Produced by Dag Gabrielsen
Pianist: Alex Lacamoire
"Drive Blind"
Written by Steve Queralt, Mark Gardener, Loz Colbert, Andy Bell
Performed by Ride
以及丝瓜肉丝的片尾曲!!!
"Samskeyti"
Written by Kjartan Sveinsson, Jon Thor Birgisson, Georg Holm, Orri P. Dyrason
Performed by Sigur Rós
有剧透!!!!请看完电影再来看!!!!!!
有剧透!!!!请看完电影再来看!!!!!!
有剧透!!!!请看完电影再来看!!!!!!
有剧透!!!!请看完电影再来看!!!!!!
有剧透!!!!请看完电影再来看!!!!!!
有剧透!!!!请看完电影再来看!!!!!!
《Mysterious skin》是一部把童年性侵犯拍得最真实和最唯美的电影:真实在对性虐场景的展现和对被性虐儿童的心理刻画,唯美在利用迷幻的英式shoe-gazing配乐从另一个感官补充描述被性虐儿童的心理。
Neil和Brian分别展现被性虐待过的儿童的两种极端心理。
Neil属于放纵型心理,成为男妓,沉溺于能带给他有教练的感觉的中年男人的性爱;Brian属于逃避型心理,自我心理防御机制使他失去被性虐的记忆,并把这段埋藏在潜意识里记忆转化为被外星人挟持的经历,在梦中屡屡梦见伏在他身上、穿着棒球鞋的“外星人”。
以下结合配乐说明。
每当Neil回想与教练的“经历”,配乐就会切换成英式迷幻、沉沦气质的shoe-gazing,不仅中和了性虐片段的真实和主题的沉重,还居然营造出不可思议的梦幻般的的唯美感(我想这也是为什么澳大利亚禁了这部电影,他们认为这电影有可能被恋童癖用来自慰或诱导儿童产生性唤起)。然而,也正是这配乐帮助淡化了教练的唆使、诱导角色,不像一些同类电影(又或是新闻报道)一味地将恋童癖魔鬼化,把一些有过性虐经历的同性恋全“归咎于”是恋童癖的错,似乎没有恋童癖就不会有这些同性恋。
相反地,电影看似轻描淡写,但却一丝不落地刻画了Neil不健康的家庭成长环境对他的影响,以及他潜在的前天性取向。在电影开头,Neil还未加入棒球队之前,当他目睹妈妈和妈妈的男朋友偷欢的时候,他的画外音独白说道:“Seeing him(妈妈的男朋友) like this, whimpering and grunting, like a helpless animal, I couldn't take my eyes off him." 诚然教练的诱导也是造成Neil成为queer很大的因素,但是很明显,Neil本身就对同性有好感,并且享受同性接触。最能体现的一点在Neil第一次见到教练的时候,他立刻就被教练捕获了:“Desire sledgehammered me. He looked like lifeguards, cowboys, firemans I'd seen in the <Playgirl> that my mom kept stashed under her bed." 教练是他的性启蒙,是他的初恋,是他的引导者。这就是为什么当Neil回忆他与教练的经历的时候配乐会是如此缠绵梦幻,因为此时的配乐是从Neil的角度来诠释教练对于他的性意义。这也解释了Neil为何会发展成为放纵型的心理,在无尽的性爱中寻找最初与教练的感觉,沉沦的配乐配上荧幕上消瘦颓废的Neil,画面与音乐配合得如此天衣无缝。
而Brian——Brian是在棒球场上被Neil和教练偶然拣选带回家的,因此Brian没法像本身就有些queer并且也爱着教练的Neil一样,接受并享受与教练的时光,所以对于Brian来说,与教练的5小时不仅是猥亵,更是强奸。然而,当Brian梦到或是努力回想自己“被外星人挟持”的经历的时候,配乐虽然不那么浪漫,但导演却仍然使用迷幻的shoe-gazing配乐。屏幕上Brian的小脸被上下颠倒了过来,很难辨清他真实的表情(更别提纯真的小演员也不可能演出什么来),但这里迷幻的配乐又在向我们传达另一种不同于Neil的信息——很多被性侵犯的儿童,由于在被性侵的过程中产生了性快感,而后经常感觉内疚与自责,不敢面对自己,发展为逃避型人格。正是因为无法接受教练和Neil对他所做的事情,也无法接受分明是在不情愿的情况下却产生的令自己羞愧又困惑的快感,Brian的心理防御机制才会把那5个小时以及之后万圣节的1小时将记忆中抹去,为的是不再让自己从每每回想中受到愧疚的折磨。但记忆虽然被抹去,但其实这段痛苦的记忆携带着更多情感逃匿到潜意识里,这也就是为什么当Brian梦到“被外星人挟持”的梦的时候,被抑制在潜意识里的各种性恐惧、性渴望都浮上水面,而配乐又在悲伤地透露着Brian痛苦、羞愧、难以启齿的性虐经历。
因此整部配乐的拣选,不仅再次体现了Gregg Araki杰出的音乐品味(他的每一部电影里都有用到post-rock, shoegazing),也体现出导演对音乐中的感情、气氛的敏锐的“审美直觉”(我管这叫artistic intuition)和对音乐于情绪的出色的掌控调配力。
----------
马虎写完,准备睡觉去了。欢迎讨论!
最后附上我最喜欢的台词几段:
Wendy: And you have to understand one thing: where normal people have a heart, Neil McCormick has a bottomless black hole. If you don't watch out, you'll get fall in and you'll get lost forever.
********************
Neil: As we sat there listening to the carolers, I wanted to tell Brian that it was over now and that everything would be okay. But that was a lie, plus I couldn't speak anyway. I wish there was some way to go back and undo the past. But there wasn't. There was nothing we could do. So I just stayed silent and tried to telepathically communicate how sorry I was about what happened. And I thought of all the grief and suffering and fucked up stuff in the world, and it made me want to escape. I wished with all my heart we could just leave this world behind. Rise like two angels in the night and magically disappear.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
最后再附上原声带:
Mysterious Skin (Music from the Film) http://www.xiami.com/album/169224
以及不包括在原声带里的歌:
"Golden Hair"
Written by Syd Barrett
Performed by Slowdive
"Galaxy"
Written by Dean Garcia, Toni Halliday
Performed by Curve
"Game Show"
Composed and Produced by Dag Gabrielsen
"Catch the Breeze"
Written by Neil Halstead
Performed by Slowdive
"Crushed"
Written by Elizabeth Fraser, Robin Guthrie, Simon Raymonde
Performed by Cocteau Twins
"Dagger"
Written by Neil Halstead
Performed by Slowdive
"I Guess I Fell in Love Last Night"
Composed and Produced by Dag Gabrielsen
Pianist: Alex Lacamoire
"I Could Do Without Her"
Composed and Produced by Dag Gabrielsen
Pianist: Alex Lacamoire
"Drive Blind"
Written by Steve Queralt, Mark Gardener, Loz Colbert, Andy Bell
Performed by Ride
以及丝瓜肉丝的片尾曲!!!
"Samskeyti"
Written by Kjartan Sveinsson, Jon Thor Birgisson, Georg Holm, Orri P. Dyrason
Performed by Sigur Rós
这篇影评有剧透