imdb上关于疯狂的石头是否是抄袭的讨论

2009-01-12 05:23:09 　　来自: 鱼非鱼 (南京)
　　
This film ripped off SNATCH!
by zhengrensterster (Thu Feb 1 2007 23:53:44)

This film is Chinese version of Snatch, the plot-line is almost the same and the film style is pretty much of Guy Ritchie style(Did they pay for remake rights?) I prefer watch something more original from China.
------------------------------
Re: This film ripped off SNATCH!
by sunyamingming (Sun Apr 15 2007 08:32:56)

agreed, although i am not against the idea of introducing western comedy masterpieces into china by having a chinese version of it.
-------------------------------------
Re: This film ripped off SNATCH!
by Koji_Kabuto (Mon Feb 4 2008 22:14:37)

as if Snatch is that original.
come on, give some serious comment.

Snatch, Lock Stock and two Smoking Barrels are also copies.
Pulp Fiction is also a collage of other films.
but nobody seems to be bothered by that.

now, just because this is a chinese film, people start complaining.
--------------------------------------
Re: This film ripped off SNATCH!
by sigu828 (Mon Apr 21 2008 08:42:57)

well said.

After pulp fiction, there are probably 100 movies following the style and no one cares. it's all about learning and improving.
-------------------------------------
Re: This film ripped off SNATCH!
by gleto (Sat Feb 9 2008 17:12:09)

it's part snatch, lady killers, and other hundreds caper movies out there.

What makes this stand above the rest -- characters and story structure. I love this film.

Save for some shoddy-quick pan editing, this movie is just genuis.
-------------------------------------
Re: This film ripped off SNATCH!
by ninedith (Tue Aug 12 2008 02:24:18)

UPDATED Tue Aug 26 2008 20:28:41
How can you say the plot line is almost the same? Actually it's more similiar to Lock, stock and two smoking barrels(especially some scenes like the duel between 2 bad guys). But Snatch? Come on, did you see any boxer or revenge in Crazy Stone?

I agree it's a Guy Ritchie style, but the style only. Just like American Gangster and the Godfather. You can't tell who steals from whom.

你认为这篇讨论：有用 1 没用

2009-01-12 11:22:27 小刚 (柿子熟了...)

　　宁浩承认过是有模仿盖.瑞奇（Guy Ritchie）。。。
　　当时，他貌似说：好的东西干嘛不学呢？？

2009-02-14 02:27:17 青鸟的方向 (可以很纯情)

　　yeah . learning and improving …

2009-02-23 17:54:39 天马

　　这个讨论还是蛮理智的`

2009-03-09 19:48:35 Gromit@茄子

　　"I prefer watch something more original from China. "
　　
　　
　　There will be. I have the faith.

2009-03-13 14:26:53 少陵野老 (Isis ♥ Bast)

　　　　Snatch, Lock Stock and two Smoking Barrels are also copies.
　　　　Pulp Fiction is also a collage of other films.
　　　　but nobody seems to be bothered by that.
　　　　
　　　　now, just because this is a chinese film, people start complaining

2009-08-24 00:31:51 motivation (一个月穿破一条JEANS，我真败家)

　　这贴的回复就少了，真的很讽刺，那些在其他贴为宁大爷打抱不平的孙子们怎么遇到外国人就成真孙子了？你们的爱国主义呢？

2011-05-04 03:08:07 黑超秘客

　　窘。。。看不懂鹰文。

2011-05-04 03:09:25 黑超秘客

　　不过这个电影我看不下去，看到一半就停了。

2011-05-14 22:34:22 Gruyarw

　　这些人阅片无数····

2011-07-04 10:38:45 Qtn

　　rip off和copy之间有区别的，前者终归有自己的想法

2011-11-03 12:41:06 清淡的图案 (凡有毅丝处，皆闻长岛雪)

　　如此的话，罗拉快跑也可算抄袭一个字头的诞生。

2011-11-24 15:51:26 chop

　　知道什么叫做有中国特色的社会主义么？
　　
　　知道什么叫做农村包围城市么？
　　
　　知道什么叫做王明么？
　　
　　知道苏联模式么？
　　
　　知道毛泽东么？
　　
　　看了盖里奇昆汀就装逼我就艹什么snatch 什么老烟枪什么低俗小说什么环状结构网状结构
　　
　　你妹啊你牛叉啊吉普赛人的英语你听的懂么中国的普罗大众有多少人能搞清楚吉普赛人的演化过程和当代地位低俗小说的那一段舞姿确实不错但是你妹的我一句文明执法就能让多少人会心一笑？
　　
　　艹看到那些人说什么抄袭我去你妹的叙事手法想想一样怎么了蒙太奇知道不？你妹的我的定军山里面老黄忠还走路了呢你妹的死昆丁里面的人物怎么不给我原创成四肢爬着走路啊？
　　
　　那帮装逼的文艺青年真是你妹的无语
　　
　　就是一帮王明
　　
　　
　　
　　～～～～～～～～～～～～～～～～～～～～～～～～～
　　
　　
　　另起一段说说举例子的意思
　　
　　对于毛个人不做任何评价只不过当时 party 要做的事就是造反造反用王明的苏联模式就是不行用了毛的经过了改变的纳入中国特色的马克思主义那就是OK 你说毛抄袭？OK 你妹的我就抄袭好了我把事情做成了革命成功了你妹的你们这些装逼的王明就是做不成这件事你的snatch的吉卜赛英语你的布拉德皮特你的盖里奇你的昆丁就不行就不如我的文明执法能逗人一笑所以你就给我死一边去
　　
　　明白你们这些装逼的傻叉王明们
　　